Located at the highly desirable northern end of Siesta Key, Bay Island is surrounded by deep water and is very popular with avid boaters. Waterfront properties in the community feature spectacular views of the intercostal waterway and downtown Sarasota skyline.
With outstanding views and convenient location, residents enjoy one of Sarasota’s most desirable neighborhoods for living on the bayfront. There are 169 single family homes in the community with a mixture of architectural styles including Mediterranean, modern and even a few beach bungalows. Real estate prices start in the $400,000's and run up to over $6 million.
The prime location at the north end of the island is convenient to the mainland and only minutes away from all of the action in downtown Sarasota. Residents also enjoy easy access to the world-famous beaches nearby.
| Total Listings: | 17 |
| Average Price: | $4,647,706 |
| Highest Price: | $11,000,000 |
| Lowest Price: | $1,395,000 |
| Average Size: | 3,426 ft² |
| Average Price Per Square Foot: | $1,454 per ft² |
Condominiums
Neighborhoods
New Search X
Welcome To Flamingo Avenue, One Of Sarasota's Most Coveted Streets. Set On Bay Island, This Classic Sarasota Home Presents An Excellent Opportunity To Own On A Street Accompanied By Iconic Estates. You'll Feel The Ocean Breeze At This Location, An...
Siesta Key Opportunity - Build Your New Home On This 21,000+ Sf Lot! The 1920s Structures On This Lot Sustained Storm Damage – Property Is Being Sold For The Land Value Only – Just Imagine The Dream Home You Could Build On A Lot That’s Just Shy Of...
Unleash Your Imagination With This Stunning Property, Perfect For Short Or Long-term Rentals, Or Simply For Your Personal Enjoyment. Both The House And Guesthouse Were Restored With Meticulous Care And Exquisite Taste Following Hurricane Milto...
Once In A Lifetime Opportunity To Restore A One-of-a-kind Ben Baldwin Mid-century Modern Home. Architect And Designer Ben Baldwin Was Recognized Internationally As The Leading Force In The Modern Movement Of American Design And Architecture. Over ...
Nestled In The Highly Sought-after Neighborhood Of Bay Island, On Siesta Key's North End, This Turnkey Key West Style Home Offers The Perfect Blend Of Historic Charm And Modern Convenience. The Spacious, Split Floor Plan Features Three Bedrooms, I...
One Or More Photo(s) Has Been Virtually Staged. Experience The Ultimate In Coastal Living With This Two-story Residence In The Highly Desirable Bay Island Shores On The World-renowned Siesta Key. Located In A Prime Waterfront Setting, This All-con...
Extraordinary Waterfront Property With Expansive Intracoastal Waterway Views Located On The Sought After North End Of Siesta Key. Now Is The Perfect Opportunity To Build Your Dream Waterfront Estate On This Exceptional Almost One-half Acre Lot In ...
Under Construction. Pre-construction, To Be Built. Experience The Pinnacle Of Modern Luxury At 838 Norsota Way, An Exquisite Estate Situated North Of Siesta Key, Expertly Crafted By M&j Pham Development. Slated For Completion In Late Summer Of 202...
Exquisite Waterfront Estate, A Boater’s Dream With Unparalleled Luxury. This Stunning Four-bedroom, 3.5-bath Waterfront Siesta Key Residence Is At The Sought-after North End Of Siesta Key, Offering 4,622 Square Feet Of Meticulously Designed Living...
New Price! Exclusive Waterfront Opportunity On Siesta Key. Discover The Pinnacle Of Waterfront Living With This Gated, Estate-sized 1.27-acre Property Located On Highly Coveted Bay Island At The Desirable North End Of Siesta Key. This Exceptional ...
Fronting Roberts Bay, This Rare Jewel Is All About The View And The Location. It Provides A Canvas For A Bayfront Estate In A Neighborhood Known For Its Exclusivity And High Real Estate Values. Old Home Has Been Torn Down Now. Imagine Your Very Ow...
An Extraordinary Chance To Own One Of Sarasota’s Most Coveted Waterfront Homesites, This 29,902-square-foot Parcel Offers An Unparalleled Setting For A Custom Estate On North Siesta Key. With 61 Feet Of Water Frontage Along The Pristine Expanse Of...
All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.
Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.
Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS.
Listing information last updated on May 17th, 2025 at 2:34am EDT.
