Bay Island

  • Description
  • Listings
  • Map
  • Contact


Located at the highly desirable northern end of Siesta Key, Bay Island is surrounded by deep water and is very popular with avid boaters. Waterfront properties in the community feature spectacular views of the intercostal waterway and downtown Sarasota skyline.

With outstanding views and convenient location, residents enjoy one of Sarasota’s most desirable neighborhoods for living on the bayfront. There are 169 single family homes in the community with a mixture of architectural styles including Mediterranean, modern and even a few beach bungalows. Real estate prices start in the $400,000's and run up to over $6 million.

The prime location at the north end of the island is convenient to the mainland and only minutes away from all of the action in downtown Sarasota. Residents also enjoy easy access to the world-famous beaches nearby.

MLS® Listing Statistics

Total Listings: 3
Average Price: $3,214,667
Highest Price: $6,900,000
Lowest Price: $1,249,000
Average Size: 4,005 ft²
Average Price Per Square Foot: $710 per ft²

Explore Other Siesta Key Communities

Homes for Sale in Bay Island Siesta Key

Map Save this Search
Sort listings by:Price, Low to High

3484 Hamilton Avenue, SARASOTA, FL - $1,249,000

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 5 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3,758 SQFT
  • 14 DOM
View details More Photos Save

Siesta Key, Bay Island, Home On Double Corner Lot. Crystal Sands Of Shell Beach Are Only A Walk Or Bike Away! This 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath Home Upstairs, And Downstairs With An Additional Two Bedrooms, Bath, With Dining & Separate Entrance (non-conformi...

3446 Anglin Drive, SARASOTA, FL - $1,495,000

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 2,450 SQFT
  • 17 DOM
View details More Photos Save

Attention All Investors! Bay Isle Pool Home Is A Rarity As It Resides In The Only Area On Siesta Keys Where Weekly Rentals Are Legally Permitted. The Home Will Stun You, With Its Meticulously Maintained Tropical Landscape And Upscale In-house Ame...

Image 2: A4496308

3821 Flamingo Avenue, SARASOTA, FL - $6,900,000

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 5 Beds
  • 5 Baths
  • 5,806 SQFT
  • 8 DOM
View details More Photos Save

This Magnificent Estate On 1 ½ Acres On The Open Bayfront Was Originally Built In 1925 By John Tuttle With Heart Pine Floors And First Cut, Clear Cut Cypress On The Beamed Ceiling And Fireplace Surround Of The Magnificent Living Room. This Exquisi...

All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.

Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.

Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS.

Listing information last updated on April 13th, 2021 at 1:07pm EDT.

Map of Bay Island

Save this Search
Sort listings by:Price, Low to High
Sort listings by: Price

Ask a Question. We are here to help!

Please provide a valid email address.