Located at the highly desirable northern end of Siesta Key, Bay Island is surrounded by deep water and is very popular with avid boaters. Waterfront properties in the community feature spectacular views of the intercostal waterway and downtown Sarasota skyline.
With outstanding views and convenient location, residents enjoy one of Sarasota’s most desirable neighborhoods for living on the bayfront. There are 169 single family homes in the community with a mixture of architectural styles including Mediterranean, modern and even a few beach bungalows. Real estate prices start in the $400,000's and run up to over $6 million.
The prime location at the north end of the island is convenient to the mainland and only minutes away from all of the action in downtown Sarasota. Residents also enjoy easy access to the world-famous beaches nearby.
| Total Listings: | 20 |
| Average Price: | $5,479,340 |
| Highest Price: | $18,500,000 |
| Lowest Price: | $999,900 |
| Average Size: | 3,672 ft² |
| Average Price Per Square Foot: | $1,453 per ft² |
Condominiums
Neighborhoods
New Search X
Highest And Best Offers Are Due By Offers Are Due By 1/7/2026 By 11;59 Pm Mountain Time....bank Owned... Located In Highly Desirable Bay Island Subdivision The Gateway To Siesta Key ... This 2700 Sqft Tropical Island Getaway Offers 4-5 Bedroo...
Restore A Piece Of Architectural History Or Build Your Dream Home On This Prime Waterfront Lot On Bay Island, The Gateway To Siesta Key And One Of The Island’s Exclusive Communities. Designed By Renowned Architect Ben Baldwin, A Leading Figure In ...
Welcome To Your Dream Family Home On Bay Island, Located On The Premier North End Of Siesta Key. This Inviting 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom Residence Is Nestled Among Beautiful Homes On Norsota Way, One Of Sarasota's Most Coveted Streets, Offering A Perf...
Welcome To 3455 Anglin Drive, Nestled In Siesta Key’s Highly Sought-after Bay Island Neighborhood. This Beautifully Renovated Coastal Home Has Been Transformed From Top To Bottom Since Its Last Purchase—featuring A Brand-new Roof, A Brand-new Pool...
Unleash Your Imagination With This Stunning Property, Perfect For Short Or Long-term Rentals, Or Simply For Your Personal Enjoyment. Both The House And Guesthouse Were Restored With Meticulous Care And Exquisite Taste Following Hurricane Milto...
Rare And Extraordinary Waterfront Offering On The Coveted North End Of Siesta Key, This Premier Bay Island Estate Parcel Presents The Ultimate Canvas For Creating A World-class Coastal Retreat. Set On Nearly Half An Acre, The Property Commands Swe...
Rare Opportunity On Prime Boating Water On Bay Isle. This Property Offers Over One Hundred Feet Of Canal Frontage, A Composite Dock, And Three Boat Lifts (16,000#,8000# & 4500#) Ensuring Seamless Access To The Water With No Bridges To The Intracoa...
Pre-construction. To Be Built. Discover Timeless Coastal Elegance In This Upcoming Traditional-style New Construction Home, Perfectly Situated In The Highly Coveted Bay Island Neighborhood On Siesta Key. Designed To Blend Modern Sophistication Wit...
Coastal Elegance On The Northern Tip Of Siesta Key. Discover Timeless Luxury In This Waterfront Estate Nestled In The Exclusive Bay Island Enclave On Siesta Key's Coveted North End. With Panoramic Views Of Roberts Bay And The Intracoastal Waterway...
One Or More Photo(s) Has Been Virtually Staged. Exceptional Waterfront - North Siesta Key's Bay Island Boater's Dream - Exerience The Best Of Coastal Living In This Elegant 4bd/4ba Residence - Just Minutes To The Intracoastal Waterway. The Home Fe...
Welcome To Casa Della Fontana — The Fountain House. Nestled On The Tranquil North End Of Siesta Key, This Gated Waterfront Estate Is A Blend Of Seaside Serenity, Architectural Distinction, And Lifestyle Luxury. Perched On A Deep, Sailboat-accessib...
Pre-construction. To Be Built. Proposed 4,250 Sq. Ft. Custom Residence .build-to-suit Opportunity To Create A Bespoke Coastal Home With Flexibility To Tailor Architecture, Layout, Finishes, And Scale To A Refined Lifestyle.located On Bay Island At...
All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.
Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.
Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS.
Listing information last updated on January 22nd, 2026 at 7:53pm EST.
