Bay Island

  • Description
  • Listings
  • Map
  • Contact

Overview

Located at the highly desirable northern end of Siesta Key, Bay Island is surrounded by deep water and is very popular with avid boaters. Waterfront properties in the community feature spectacular views of the intercostal waterway and downtown Sarasota skyline.

With outstanding views and convenient location, residents enjoy one of Sarasota’s most desirable neighborhoods for living on the bayfront. There are 169 single family homes in the community with a mixture of architectural styles including Mediterranean, modern and even a few beach bungalows. Real estate prices start in the $400,000's and run up to over $6 million.

The prime location at the north end of the island is convenient to the mainland and only minutes away from all of the action in downtown Sarasota. Residents also enjoy easy access to the world-famous beaches nearby.

MLS® Listing Statistics

Total Listings: 9
Average Price: $6,992,667
Highest Price: $22,000,000
Lowest Price: $1,900,000
Average Size: 4,886 ft²
Average Price Per Square Foot: $1,266 per ft²

Explore Other Siesta Key Communities

Homes for Sale in Bay Island Siesta Key

Map Save this Search
Sort listings by:Price, Low to High

617 Siesta Drive, SARASOTA, FL - $1,900,000

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 5 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 2,709 SQFT
  • 233 DOM
View details More Photos Save

Welcome To The Ultimate Island Getaway On Siesta Key - The Number One Beach In The Nation! This Stunning Home Is Just A Short Five-minute Walk From The Private Shell Beach, Or A Five-minute Drive From The Center Of The Village, Where You'll Find W...

3455 Anglin Drive, SARASOTA, FL - $2,350,000

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 3 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 2,558 SQFT
  • 13 DOM
View details More Photos Save

Absolutely Ideal! Completely Renovated 3-bedroom, 3.5 Bath Pool Home On Siesta Key’s Coveted Bay Island. Every Detail Is Meticulously Executed And Move-in Ready! From The Circular Driveway, You Are Welcomed By Antique Wooden Gates That Open To A G...

Image 2: A4543285

3532 Flamingo Avenue, SARASOTA, FL - $3,589,000

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 3 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 3,162 SQFT
  • 188 DOM
View details More Photos Save

A Boater's Dream Offering 70ft Of Shoreline On The Hanson Bayou. A Unique Combination Of Sophistication And Luxury Awaits You In The Quaint Neighborhood Of Bay Island. Enjoy Watching Dolphins Play In Your Backyard! Conveniently Located On The Nor...

Image 3: A4543853

3810 Flamingo Avenue, SARASOTA, FL - $3,800,000

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 4 Beds
  • 5 Baths
  • 3,960 SQFT
  • 189 DOM
View details More Photos Save

Revel In The Spectacular Siesta Key Lifestyle In One Of Sarasota's Finest Neighborhoods With Luxury Homes That Redefine Island Living. With Serenity And Privacy, Along With Easy Big Water Access, You'll Feel Right At Home In This Fully Furnished S...

Image 4: A4550987

3726 Flamingo Avenue, SARASOTA, FL - $4,550,000

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 3 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 4,000 SQFT
  • 95 DOM
View details More Photos Save

Enjoy Waterfront Living At Its Best In This Beautiful 2019 Custom-built Home By Jonas Yoder Homes Located On A Private Street On The North End Of World-famous Siesta Key. This Impressive Residence Is Perfectly Positioned To Take Advantage Of Its W...

Image 5: A4546740

3722 Flamingo Avenue, SARASOTA, FL - $6,750,000

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 5 Beds
  • 7 Baths
  • 4,985 SQFT
  • 155 DOM
View details More Photos Save

Pre-construction. To Be Built. A Dream Home Built By Well-respected Voigt Brothers Construction On 95 Ft Of Water Frontage. Great Boating Waters On Hanson Bayou With Easy Access And No Bridges To The Bay. The Home Itself Will Be 4985 Sqft With An ...

Image 6: A4554867

749 Freeling Drive, SIESTA KEY, FL - $7,995,000

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 4 Beds
  • 6 Baths
  • 6,827 SQFT
  • 52 DOM
View details More Photos Save

The Incomparable Casa Della Fontana…the Fountain House… Sits Along 125’ Of Siesta Key’s Riviera. It Can Accommodate Up To A 60’ Yacht In This Protected, Deep-water Basin With Direct Access To The Intracoastal And Gulf Of Mexico. This Gated, Euro...

Image 7: A4552060

799 Freeling Drive, SARASOTA, FL - $10,000,000

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 4 Beds
  • 5 Baths
  • 7,636 SQFT
  • 80 DOM
View details More Photos Save

Welcome To Vivre Le Rêve (living The Dream), A One-of-a-kind Estate Situated On One Of The Most Desirable Streets On Bay Island At The North End Of Siesta Key. The Freeling Drive Peninsula Is Sited On One Of Sarasota’s Most Protected And Most Beau...

Image 8: A4555451

3799 Flamingo Avenue, SARASOTA, FL - $22,000,000

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 4 Beds
  • 6 Baths
  • 8,138 SQFT
  • 17 DOM
View details More Photos Save

Discover Your Very Own Island Paradise On World-famous Siesta Key. Located On The North End Of Siesta Key, This Awe-inspiring Estate Was Brilliantly Created To Deliver The Perfect Balance Between Architecture, Design, And Home Décor While Taking F...

All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.

Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.

Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS.

Listing information last updated on February 4th, 2023 at 12:18am EST.

Map of Bay Island

Save this Search
Sort listings by:Price, Low to High
Sort listings by: Price

Ask a Question. We are here to help!

Please provide a valid email address.