As one of Sarasota's oldest neighborhoods, Indian Beach offers an eclectic mix of architectural styles. You will find some of our area's most impressive homes along the waterfront. Residents enjoy breathtaking sunsets of Sarasota Bay.
Below are all of the homes for sale in the Indian Beach neighborhood of Sarasota Florida. All real estate listings are updated daily from the Multiple Listing Service (MLS). To learn more about any of these properties or receive email updates when new listings hit the market, simply give us a call at 941-544-6467 or send us an email. We are here to help!
… Read More| Total Listings: | 19 |
| Average Price: | $3,742,732 |
| Highest Price: | $22,000,000 |
| Lowest Price: | $314,900 |
| Average Size: | 3,310 ft² |
| Average Price Per Square Foot: | $867 per ft² |
Neighborhoods
New Search X
Set On 2.4 Gated Acres With An Impressive 240 Feet Of Pristine Waterfront, This Rare Sarasota Compound Offers Over 10,000 Square Feet Of Pure Privacy, Serenity, And Elevated Coastal Living. Perfectly Positioned In The Heart Of The City Yet Worlds ...
An Architectural Masterpiece On Sarasota Bay. Commanding One Of Sarasota’s Most Spectacular Bayfront Settings, This Gated Estate Blends Cutting-edge Engineering With Timeless Coastal Living. Built On 55 Deep Concrete Piles Extending 30 Feet Underg...
Nestled On 1.1 Acres Of Pristine Bayfront Along Sarasota Bay, Etowah Stands As A Timeless Icon Of Sarasota’s Rich Architectural Heritage, Offering Sweeping, Wide-open Bay Views To The North And South, From The Manicured Lawn At The Water’s Edge Al...
189 Feet Of Rare Boatable Water Frontage. Already Cleared And Elevated In Preparation For A Large Contemporary Estate, This Nearly 1 Acre Lot Offers Generous Buildable Space And Valuable Privacy For Your Future Vision. This Extraordinary Waterfron...
Exotic And Extremely Private Bay Front Property On The Market For The First Time In 40 Years. In Fact, This Is Only The Third Time It’s Been Available In 100 Years. Travel Back In Time To Find Ancient Oaks And Large Palms, Banyans, And Cedars. It’...
Exotic And Extremely Private Bay Front Property On The Market For The First Time In 40 Years. In Fact, This Is Only The Third Time It’s Been Available In 100 Years. Travel Back In Time To Find Ancient Oaks And Large Palms, Banyans, And Cedars. It’...
One Or More Photo(s) Has Been Virtually Staged. • Welcome To Beyond The Gates, Where Timeless Elegance Meets Coastal Serenity In The Heart Of The Historic Indian Beach-sapphire Shores Neighborhood. Perfectly Nestled Between Sarasota College Of Art...
A Rare Chance To Own A Prime Bayfront Property In Sarasota’s Highly Desirable Sapphire Shores / Indian Beach Neighborhood. Positioned On A 0.51-acre Lot With 136 Feet Of Direct Sarasota Bay Frontage, 820 Indian Beach Combines Unobstructed Water Vi...
A Rare Chance To Own A Prime Bayfront Property In Sarasota’s Highly Desirable Sapphire Shores / Indian Beach Neighborhood. Positioned On A 0.51-acre Lot With 136 Feet Of Direct Sarasota Bay Frontage, 820 Indian Beach Combines Unobstructed Water Vi...
Amazing Opportunity To Create Your Waterfront Estate In Sapphire Shores, Where History, Culture, And Growth Meet. This 16,378 Sq. Ft. Lot Offers 87 Feet Of Water Frontage, A Private Dock, And Direct Access To Sarasota Bay. Positioned Along A Quiet...
Amazing Opportunity To Create Your Waterfront Estate In Sapphire Shores, Where History, Culture, And Growth Meet. This 16,378 Sq. Ft. Lot Offers 87 Feet Of Water Frontage, A Private Dock, And Direct Access To Sarasota Bay. Positioned Along A Quiet...
Significant Price Improvement Of Over $200,000!! Great Opportunity To Own Over Half An Acre Of Land In Indian Beach Sapphire Shores - Must Be Seen In Person. Schedule A Viewing Today! Tucked Beneath A Canopy Of Lush, Tropical Greenery In Iconic In...
Significant Price Improvement Of Over $200,000!! Nestled In A Canopy Of Lush, Tropical Greenery In Indian Beach, This Distinctive Property Captures The Spirit Of One Of Sarasota’s Most Sought-after Neighborhoods. A Unique Flag Lot Of Over Half An ...
O La La! Shangri-la! Fall In Love At First Sight! Nestled Under Leafy Green Trees, This Enchanting Charmer Comes With A Free-standing Studio Complete With Kitchenette, Full Bathroom, Separate Entrance, And Outdoor Nook Blooming With Jasmine Linger...
Enjoy The Best Of Florida Living In This Beautifully Maintained Mid-century Modern Home. Featuring 4 Bedrooms, 2 1/2 Bathrooms, An Extended 1 Car Garage And Over 2000 Square Feet Of Thoughtfully Designed Living Space. This Open Floor Plan Offers A...
This Charming 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom Pool Home Is Situated In Flood Zone X, Meaning Flood Insurance Is Not Mandatory. It Boasts A Lovely Fenced Backyard And Is Conveniently Located Near All Essential Amenities. Recent Updates Include Hot Water Hea...
Step Into This Updated Mid-century 3-bedroom, 2-bath Home With A 2-car Garage And A Private Above-ground Pool, Ideally Situated For Both Personal Enjoyment And Investment Potential. This Property Offers The Rare Opportunity To Generate Projected S...
Welcome To 839 40th Street, Located West Of The Trail In Sarasota's Desirable Indian Beach Sapphire Shores/museum District. This Charming Home Is Just Steps Away From A Picturesque Neighborhood Beach Along Sarasota Bay, Renowned For Its Breathta...
Large Sarasota Bungalow Situated On An Expansive 125 X 135 Lot Totaling Over .38 Acres, Just .2 Miles North Of Downtown Sarasota. Enjoy Walking Distance To The The Ringling, Sarasota Bayfront For Magnificent Sunsets, Asolo Theatre, And A Variety O...
All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.
Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.
Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS.
Listing information last updated on March 14th, 2026 at 5:23pm EDT.
Showcased by century-old oaks and Sarasota Bay, residents live in an atmosphere of "Old-Florida" where five to six-story oak trees draped in Spanish moss tower as canopies across lawns and streets creating a charming lighting effect. You'll see students and friendly neighbors walking their dogs in this artsy community or sitting outside at one of the area's cafes.
Real estate options are quite diverse with cottages, bungalows and a few two-story Colonial and several 1950's style ranches. Large waterfront homes line the lots on Sarasota Bay. There are a diverse array of residents too, including retirees, art students, old families and some of the most prominent residents of Sarasota.
Indian Beach and Sapphire Shores make up Sarasota's Museum area. A variety of cultural and educational amenities are located nearby including the John and Mable Ringling Museums as well as the highly regarded Ringling School of Art and Design.
Homeowners Association Information
Nearby Schools
